54 Comments

thanks for this. several copies of the book are available for free on Internet Archive if anyone is interested. Reminds me of Victor Frankl.

Expand full comment

When I was in my 20s and 30s, I practiced aikido about 15 hours a week. One day when I was 25, I met a doctor from Vietnam maybe 20 years older than me, who was delighted to hear that I did that. He said, "Aikido helped me survive a prison camp!" This astonished me a bit, until he explained. Aikido (correctly instructed) had taught him mindfulness and to think only about the next thing he had to do. His explanation matched that to be found from Victor Herman in his book "Coming Out of the Ice". Herman was an American who went to Russia to work at a plant that Ford built for Stalin, and like almost all his colleagues, landed in the gulag, but was one of the few who survived. Very much like the Vietnamese doctor told me, he wrote that the key to survival was to focus only on the next thing to be done. Herman said that many literally worried themselves to death in the gulag thinking about their past, their future, etc.

"Coming Out of the Ice" is a powerful memoir that was taken off the market when it was high in the bestseller lists, apparently because the New York publisher had gotten a deal to publish Brezhnev's autobiography if they pulled Herman's book off the shelves. He found a large stock of them still unsold somewhere and sold them from his home until they sold out, and then the book was republished by a company somewhere in the Plains states. It has also long been out of print, and used copies of the paperback go for $300 on Amazon, and the hardcover goes for over $500.

Expand full comment

“The tiniest window bringing light will always dominate the bleak and oppressive walls.”

Such an inspiring quote. Thank you Ted for bringing this fascinating person to my attention.

I feel like live music acts as a lantern

during this time of global crisis, and find hope in the idea that music will “dominate the bleak and oppressive walls.”

Expand full comment

Several copies available on vialibri.net

Expand full comment

I know that book well. I was shocked to hear that a reader for the New York Review of Books publishing arm rejected the title for reprint. I'm happy to have a British second edition from 1961.

Expand full comment
Apr 26, 2023Liked by Ted Gioia

I’m a fairly jaundiced sixty-six year-old novelist who has probably spent too many years critiquing the work of young writers in MFA programs. It’s hard to impress me, and even harder to move me, and harder yet to make me say “thank you for allowing me to read this.” Thank you for allowing me to read this, Ted. It made today a better, more rewarding day. You do that again and again.

Expand full comment

Thanks for bringing this author to our attention.

Solitude - or more specifically the absence of fear of solitude - is indeed freedom. Even the most introverted of us may ultimately be social creatures that need social contact, but becoming comfortable with your own alone-ness is indeed one of the most liberating skills one can have.

Expand full comment

The book needs to be back in print. Thanks for the synopsis.

Expand full comment

Thanks for this little-known story of human endurance. Now I wonder how Christopher Burney's hard-won mindfulness affected the rest of his life. Also, I hope I remember the things he did if I'm ever in similar straits!

Expand full comment
Apr 25, 2023·edited Apr 25, 2023

"All of humanity's problems stem from man's inability to sit quietly in a room alone," wrote the French philosopher Blaise Pascal.

Burney and Pascal were both blessed with that most pointed of tools: a mind.

What will those addicted to video screens do?

Expand full comment

This was a captivating essay to start my morning! I found it interesting that he discovered that rhythm provided a sense of liberty. It reminded me of walking the Camino pilgrimage in Spain, where I would just hear the rhythmic crunching of gravel under my feet for hours and nothing much else; it provided a calm sense of serenity that I had not even been looking for.

"If mindfulness is possible in those circumstances—with so little to see, touch, hear, or taste—imagine what riches it can offer to us, with the whole world at hand." Having the whole world at our hand is what makes mindfulness so elusive in our overstimulated, distracted routines. One of the practices that many of us are in need of is 'cognitive liberty' as we are become increasingly enslaved by algorithms that tug at us every few seconds. See 'From feeding Moloch to 'Digital Minimalism'. https://schooloftheunconformed.substack.com/p/from-feeding-moloch-to-digital-minimalism

Expand full comment

I dimly remember reading about a musician being imprisoned , without access to his instrument. When he was released, he gave a concert. Those who had known him and the fact of his situation in the prison were amazed at his level of musicianship after release. His explanation was that he had visualized his instrument and “practiced” every day. I think I found this in a book about sports visualization, but nights when I have trouble sleeping I try creating chords in my mind, seeing the fretboard or keyboard and spelling the chords. I would love to know what the rest of Burney’s life was like…did he survive to the end of the war? What was he like then?

Expand full comment

Superb piece on Christopher Burney. As a complement, you might look at Jim Stockdale, fighter pilot shot down over Vietnam, seven and a half years the leader of our POWs in the Hanoi Hilton, and a devotee of stoicism.

Expand full comment

Being a bibliophile, I noticed a lot of book marketing prioritizes different demographics when it comes to the war. Which also takes second place after Holocaust lit. Saying that only to mention a reality in the publishing world: accounts of British spies do not rank high, just as Polish Holocaust lit is often lower in the ranks because it's not "West" enough. (like Kazimierz Moczarskis Conversations with an Executioner) I would have thought a book like this would still be in print in Britain. Sad to see that after Burney's service, he's been forgotten by the publishing world.

You have definitely made a stunningly great case for its continued readership. I'm glad to add it to my reading list.

Expand full comment

ted…. there are a few other books out by those who lived in solitary confinement for many years…. jay jarvis masters has a few books out that i highly recommend.. also, albert woodfox wrote one a few years ago.. finally, someone earlier mentioned nelson mandela and his autobio. long walk to freedom.. they are all really great books..

Expand full comment

Makes me think of Notes of a Dead House, Dostoevsky’s memoir about his four years in a hard labor camp. Intense stuff. Ditto the book Gulag Archipelago about the concentrations camps in communist Russia in the Stalin years. Ruthless, tortured prison experiences. Music and solitude to survive make a lot of sense. Thinking. Honestly sometimes I think, Lock me up but give me 500 books and I’d be fine.

https://michaelmohr.substack.com/p/dostoevsky-russian-wizard

Expand full comment